WhatsApp, Meta Platforms want tribunal to quash FCCPC penalty on 22 grounds - Newstrends
Connect with us

News

WhatsApp, Meta Platforms want tribunal to quash FCCPC penalty on 22 grounds

Published

on

Meta Platforms Inc.

WhatsApp, Meta Platforms want tribunal to quash FCCPC penalty on 22 grounds

WhatsApp and its parent company, Meta Platforms Incorporated, have cited 22 reasons why the Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (FCCPC) order imposing a $220 million penalty should be set aside by the Competition and Consumer Protection Tribunal, among others. 

This is detailed in their notice of appeal against the FCCPC, which was exclusively seen by Nairametrics. 

Newstrends previously reported that the FCCPC, an agency under the Federal Ministry of Industry, Trade and Investment (FMITI), had imposed a $220,000,000 penalty on Meta Platforms Incorporated over alleged discriminatory practices against Nigerian data and consumers. 

In a statement signed by Dr. Adamu Abdullahi, Acting Chief Executive Officer of the FCCPC on July 26, 2024,the penalty followed a joint investigation by the Commission and the Nigeria Data Protection Commission (NDPC) into Meta Platforms’ conduct, privacy policies, and practices between May 2021 and December 2023, a period of 38 months. 

According to the statement, in May 2021, the Commission had directed WhatsApp LLC and Meta Platforms, Inc. (formerly called Facebook Inc.) to defend themselves regarding its investigative report, which detailed how their conduct allegedly violated relevant data laws. 

Meta was said to have provided some information in response to the requests and summons under the joint investigation. 

However, the Commission disclosed that the investigation concluded that Meta Platforms had engaged in conduct constituting continuing infringements of Nigeria’s consumer protection and data laws over an extended period. 

It expressed concerns about Meta’s allegedly abusive and invasive practices affecting data subjects and consumers in Nigeria.  

These included unauthorized use of personal data, discriminatory treatment compared to other regions with similar regulations, and the exploitation of market dominance to enforce privacy policies that collect personal information without giving consumers the option to consent or refuse. 

“The Final Order of the Commission mandates steps and actions Meta Parties must take to comply with prevailing laws and cease the exploitation of Nigerian consumers and market abuse, as well as desist from future similar or other conduct/practices that do not meet nationally applicable standards and undermine the rights of consumers,” the FCCPC statement partly reads. 

WhatsApp, Meta platforms grounds of appeal 

In the social media giants’ 22 reasons listed in their notice of appeal seen by Nairametrics, their legal team argued that the FCCPC erred in all the findings, directions, and decisions contained in its orders.  

READ ALSO:

They are leveraging their appeal to ask the tribunal to quash the FCCPC’s orders in their entirety. 

Here are the reasons listed by WhatsApp and Meta Platforms: 

Vague Rights of Nigerian Users 

 Meta Platforms insisted that the FCCPC’s directive to “immediately reinstate the rights of Nigerian users to self-determine and control the use, processing, sharing, or transfer of their data” is unreasonably vague, creating excessive uncertainty. 

  According to Meta, the obligation requested by the FCCPC does not consider the operational complexities inherent in the WhatsApp service, thereby imposing an impossible burden on the appellants. 

Ambiguous privacy policy order 

 Meta insisted that Nigerian users are fully at liberty to reject its privacy policy by declining to accept WhatsApp’s Terms of Service and not using the WhatsApp service. 

 Furthermore, it argued that the privacy policy order by FCCPC is ambiguous because WhatsApp had updated its privacy policy in a format that allows Nigerian users to fully express their legitimate rights prior to the initiation of the FCCPC’s investigation. 

Unjustifiable order on data sharing between platforms 

 Meta insisted that it is unjustifiable for the FCCPC to order it to immediately halt sharing WhatsApp user information with other Facebook companies and third parties until users have voluntarily consented to each aspect of how their data will be used. 

 It submitted that forcing WhatsApp to rely on consent for its data sharing is discriminatory, contrary to the express provisions of the law, and disregards industry-standard practices. 

Meta privacy policy not subject to FCCPC approval 

 WhatsApp and Meta insisted that Nigerian law does not require that the privacy policy of a data controller be approved in advance by either the Commission or the Nigeria Data Protection Commission (NDPC), nor does the law authorize any of the agencies to insist on such prior approval. 

Meta can’t revert to its data sharing practices of 2016 

 Meta insisted that there is no legal basis for the Commission to direct the appellants to revert to the “data sharing practices adopted in 2016” (which allowed users to consent or withhold consent). 

It maintained that the companies’ data practices do not violate Nigerian law and, therefore, do not warrant such a directive from the Commission. 

Unclear blockage of WhatsApp data transfer to Facebook 

 The appellants submitted that the instruction to stop transferring data from WhatsApp to Facebook and other third parties without explicit consent from users is unclear, as one can make full use of the WhatsApp messaging service without signing up for a Facebook account or any other Meta product. 

READ ALSO:

No need for written assurance to FCCPC 

The appellants stated that they had not taken any steps detrimental to the interests of their Nigerian users and that there was no need for the FCCPC to mandate them to submit a “written assurance” assuring it would not infringe on consumers’ rights. 

Erroneous proposed remedy package for consumers 

The appellants argued that they have no remedy “package” to comply with. 

 Furthermore, they contended that the 15-day timeframe stipulated by the order for the execution of the “Proposed Remedy Package” for consumers is inadequate and does not provide an adequate period for implementation. 

Meta can’t pay FCCPC $35,000 as investigation cost 

 The appellants submitted that the Commission erred in law when it ordered that the “Meta Parties shall reimburse the Commission the cost of the investigation in the sum of Thirty-Five Thousand U.S. Dollars only ($35,000.00) (at prevailing exchange rate where applicable) under Section 23(2)(f) of the FCCPA.” 

They argued that there is no legal basis for the Commission to direct the appellants to reimburse the costs of conducting its investigation, as they are not obligated by or liable in law to pay these costs. 

$220 million penalty is hefty 

The appellants also argued that the FCCPC denied them a fair hearing by imposing a hefty penalty without giving them an opportunity to understand the means by which the penalty would be calculated and to respond to the calculation of the proposed amount. 

Impossible to build Data Consent Mechanisms 

 The appellants argued that contrary to the FCCPC’s order on compliance, it would be impossible to identify and build a consent mechanism for each data point processed by Nigerian consumers. They added that doing so would be “extremely expensive.“ 

FCCPC can investigate Meta without requiring the presence of Its personnel 

The appellants argued that FCCPC experts can always conduct data handling compliance audits of Meta, without needing its personnel.  

“Further, the appellants have no physical presence in Nigeria, thus negating any need for, or point in having, an audit from the Commission,” they stated. 

Meta Can’t be compelled to obtain FCCPC prior approval 

 The appellants stated that the Commission has no powers to compel them to obtain the approval of the Commission or the NDPC prior to the publication of its privacy policy within ten days. 

 They further argued that updates to its privacy policy require extensive engagement with stakeholders across WhatsApp, and substantial amendments can take months to implement. 

Proposed remedy package will take time to implement 

 The appellants argued that it is not technically possible to implement any proposed remedy package for Nigerian consumers (whose rights have been allegedly infringed upon) within 15 days, as directed by the FCCPC. 

WhatsApp, Meta does not coerce Nigerian consumers 

The appellants argued that if FCCPC’s Order Number 5 of the Final Order is intended to reference “tying in the sense of coercion by an allegedly dominant party of a consumer to accept a tied product as a condition of receiving a tying product, leading to the foreclosure of competition,” no such thing exists in WhatsApp or Meta. 

Meta wasn’t formally probed by FCCPC 

 The appellants argued that the Commission erred when it ordered Meta to produce information in the investigation of WhatsApp without formally initiating an investigation of Meta. 

They argued that WhatsApp is a distinct legal entity from Meta. 

No need to penalize Meta 

The appellants further argued that there was no evidence before the Commission showing that WhatsApp was acting on behalf of Meta, and therefore no evidence to warrant treating Meta as a target of the Commission’s orders. 

Fair hearing 

WhatsApp and Meta argued that the Commission erred in issuing the Final Order because it failed to consider the submissions made by the appellants before issuing the final order, thereby violating their right to a fair hearing. 

 WhatsApp, Meta was not allowed to query the calculation of the penalty 

 The appellants urged the tribunal to hold that the Commission was in error because it did not afford them an opportunity to make representations on the feasible period required for compliance with its decisions, the amount of the penalty imposed, or the methodology employed in calculating the penalty. 

FCCPC made no findings against WhatsApp, Meta 

The appellants’ legal team also argued that the Final Order issued by the Commission is fundamentally flawed due to its failure to disclose any findings of fact or law or to provide reasons for the decisions or penalties. 

FCCPC fined WhatsApp and Meta without the signature of its Executive Chairman or Vice Chairman 

The appellants argued that the position of the Executive Vice-Chairman of the FCCPC was allegedly vacant at the time the Final Order was signed. 

It stated: 

“To be clear, while President Bola Tinubu appointed Mr. Olatunji Bello on June 24, 2024, as the Executive Vice-Chairman of the Commission, his appointment had, at all material times, not been confirmed by the Senate in accordance with Section 5 of the FCCPA. 

“Thus, it effectively means that the position of the Executive Vice-Chairman was vacant on the date shown on the face of the Final Order.” 

Unreasonable orders 

WhatsApp and Meta believe that the Final Order of the FCCPC “is unreasonable and against the weight of evidence.” 

They urged the Tribunal to allow their appeal and set aside all of the decisions reached in the Final Order of the Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission. 

What you should know 

Per data from Statista, there were nearly 41.6 million Facebook users in Nigeria as of May 2023, which is 18.5% of the country’s population. 

Following the FCCPC’s orders, WhatsApp reacted, saying, “In 2021, we went to users globally to explain how talking to businesses, among other things, would work. While there was a lot of confusion then, it has actually proven quite popular.” 

Meanwhile, fines such as the ones imposed against Meta are not uncommon. Last year, the European Data Protection Agency fined the tech giant Facebook a record €1.2 billion for not complying with the EU’s privacy regulations. 

The Irish Data Protection Commission stated that Meta, the parent company of Facebook, violated the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) by transferring large amounts of European Facebook users’ personal data to the United States without adequately protecting it from U.S. data surveillance practices. 

Amazon had previously been fined €746 million by Luxembourg, and the Irish regulator imposed four fines on Meta’s platforms—Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp—ranging from €225 million to €405 million between 2021 and 2023. 

Over the past five years, Big Tech companies Amazon, Meta, and Google have faced some of the largest fines imposed under the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) privacy laws. 

The legality or illegality of the recent penalties and orders against WhatsApp and Meta Platforms is now a matter for the courts to determine. 

WhatsApp, Meta Platforms want tribunal to quash FCCPC penalty on 22 grounds

Loading

News

2027: Rufai Oseni Tackles Segun Sowunmi Over Media Decorum, Press Freedom

Published

on

ARISE News Channel’s The Morning Show anchor, Rufai Oseni

2027: Rufai Oseni Tackles Segun Sowunmi Over Media Decorum, Press Freedom

 

A fresh war of words has erupted between Arise News presenter Rufai Oseni and Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) chieftain Segun Sowunmi over press freedom, journalistic independence and the conduct of media practitioners ahead of the 2027 general elections.

 

Oseni reportedly fired back at Sowunmi following comments concerning the need for journalists to maintain professional decorum while engaging political figures, accusing politicians of applying double standards when confronted with critical questions from the media.

 

The exchange, which has generated discussions in political and media circles, comes amid growing political activities and realignments ahead of the 2027 general elections.

 

According to reports published on Monday, November 16, 2026, Oseni questioned what he considered an inconsistency in Sowunmi’s position on media conduct, arguing that political actors should not demand restraint from journalists while expecting favourable treatment or seeking to limit critical scrutiny.

 

2027: Rufai Oseni Tackles Segun Sowunmi Over Media Decorum, Press Freedom

Loading

Continue Reading

News

Tinubu Unveils 5-Year Plan to End Insecurity, Approves Recruitment of 78,000 Soldiers, Police Officers

Published

on

Tinubu Unveils 5-Year Plan to End Insecurity, Approves Recruitment of 78,000 Soldiers, Police Officers
President Bola Ahmed Tinubu
Tinubu Unveils 5-Year Plan to End Insecurity, Approves Recruitment of 78,000 Soldiers, Police Officers

ABUJA – President Bola Ahmed Tinubu is preparing to implement a comprehensive five-year strategic defence operations plan aimed at tackling terrorism, banditry, kidnapping and other security threats across Nigeria.

The All Progressives Congress (APC) Presidential Campaign Council (PCC) announced on Sunday, November 15, 2026, that the Five-Year Strategic Defence Operations Plan was ready, describing it as a major component of the administration’s efforts to strengthen national security and improve the operational capacity of security agencies.

The council’s spokesperson, Dele Alake, disclosed this in a statement, explaining that the proposed framework would provide a long-term strategy for aligning defence priorities, military requirements, equipment acquisition, personnel development and government expenditure with Nigeria’s security challenges.

According to Alake, the plan is designed to promote a more coordinated, intelligence-led, technology-enabled and prevention-oriented approach to addressing insecurity.

He said the initiative would strengthen the country’s security architecture and improve the ability of the military and other security agencies to respond to emerging threats.

Alake also claimed that military operations conducted across the country over the past three years had resulted in the elimination of more than 15,000 Boko Haram terrorists and bandits.

He further claimed that over 130,000 Boko Haram fighters and their dependants had surrendered through Operation Safe Corridor, the Federal Government’s rehabilitation programme for former insurgents.

The figures, according to the campaign council, demonstrate the administration’s combination of military operations and non-military interventions in addressing insecurity.

Expansion of Army Divisions, Recruitment of 28,000 Soldiers

As part of efforts to strengthen military operations, Tinubu has approved the creation of four additional Nigerian Army divisions and the restructuring of existing military formations.

Alake said the reforms were intended to expand operational coverage, decentralise military activities and enable troops to respond more quickly to security threats in different parts of the country.

READ ALSO:

The President has also approved the establishment of two additional Army depots in Osogbo, Osun State, and Amasiri-Edda, Ebonyi State, to increase the military’s recruitment and training capacity.

Each facility is designed to accommodate 6,000 recruits at a time, giving the two depots a combined capacity of 12,000 trainees.

According to Alake, 5,210 recruits are already undergoing training at the Osogbo facility.

The council also disclosed that Tinubu had approved the recruitment of an additional 28,000 soldiers to increase the military’s manpower and strengthen its presence in areas facing security challenges.

The expansion is expected to address manpower shortages, improve deployment capacity and enable the military to respond more effectively to attacks by terrorists, bandits and other criminal groups.

50,000 Additional Police Officers Approved

Beyond the military, the administration is also planning a significant expansion of the Nigeria Police Force.

Alake disclosed that Tinubu had approved the recruitment of 50,000 additional police officers as part of broader efforts to strengthen internal security and improve policing across the country.

The proposed recruitment, alongside the additional soldiers, represents an intended expansion of 78,000 personnel across the military and police.

The campaign council said the initiative would improve security coverage, reinforce law enforcement and strengthen the country’s capacity to tackle kidnapping, armed robbery, terrorism and other criminal activities.

New Military Barracks, Improved Welfare

The five-year security strategy also places emphasis on military infrastructure, accommodation and personnel welfare.

One of the projects highlighted by the council is a proposed 700-unit military barracks in Ikere-Ekiti, Ekiti State.

The facility is designed to provide accommodation and operational support for military personnel, with the broader objective of improving their working and living conditions.

Alake said the administration recognises that investments in equipment and manpower must be supported by adequate infrastructure, training and welfare provisions to improve the effectiveness of security personnel.

He added that the expansion of military training facilities would help accelerate recruitment and ensure more soldiers are available for deployment.

Technology, Intelligence to Drive Security Operations

Another major component of the proposed five-year defence plan is the use of intelligence, surveillance and modern technology to improve security operations.

According to Alake, the administration intends to ensure that defence spending and operational decisions are guided by identified threats, national security priorities and clearly defined military requirements.

The approach is expected to strengthen intelligence gathering, improve coordination among security agencies, enhance combat readiness and address gaps in military capabilities.

The campaign council said the strategy would also promote better utilisation of available resources and reduce unnecessary expenditure in the defence sector.

The proposed framework is intended to address multiple security threats, including terrorism, banditry, kidnapping and other forms of organised criminality.

Tinubu Reaffirms Commitment to Defeating Insecurity

The announcement comes amid persistent security challenges in several parts of Nigeria, including attacks on rural communities, mass kidnappings, killings and displacement.

Tinubu had earlier reaffirmed his administration’s determination to overcome insecurity while addressing supporters at an APC political gathering in Dutse, Jigawa State, on November 10.

The President said his administration was strengthening the armed forces and police to improve their ability to protect lives and property.

He also promised to improve the welfare of security personnel, irrespective of their backgrounds or deployment locations.

“We will conquer insecurity. We’ve been through many wars. We will defeat our enemies. Enemies of unity, enemies of stability. Enemies of hope. I assure you that we are doing that,” Tinubu said.

The announcement of the five-year strategic defence plan provides further details of the administration’s proposed approach to tackling the country’s security challenges.

However, the success of the initiative will depend on effective implementation, adequate funding, improved intelligence coordination, accountability and the ability of security agencies to translate the proposed reforms into measurable improvements in public safety.

The APC Presidential Campaign Council said the plan would strengthen Nigeria’s defence architecture and provide a coordinated framework for responding to both existing and emerging security threats.

 

Tinubu Unveils 5-Year Plan to End Insecurity, Approves Recruitment of 78,000 Soldiers, Police Officers

Loading

Continue Reading

News

Chatham House Protest: UK-Based Lawyer Alleges Anti-Amupitan Demonstrators Were Paid Actors

Published

on

INEC Chairman, Professor Joash Amupitan

Chatham House Protest: UK-Based Lawyer Alleges Anti-Amupitan Demonstrators Were Paid Actors

 

LONDON — Fresh controversy has emerged over the protest against the Chairman of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), Professor Joash Amupitan, outside Chatham House in London, following allegations by a United Kingdom-based Nigerian lawyer, Otunba Dayo Babalola, that the demonstrators were allegedly paid to stage the confrontation.

Babalola dismissed the demonstration as an attempt by a small group of individuals to create a misleading impression about the position of Nigerians living in the United Kingdom on the leadership of the electoral commission.

The controversy followed Amupitan’s engagement at Chatham House, where he reportedly discussed electoral reforms and measures being considered by INEC to strengthen the credibility and integrity of Nigeria’s electoral process ahead of the 2027 general elections.

However, shortly after the engagement, a group of protesters reportedly confronted the INEC chairman outside the venue, surrounding his vehicle, chanting slogans and demanding his resignation over allegations of compromised electoral integrity.

The demonstrators, estimated by eyewitnesses to number between 10 and 15, reportedly attempted to block the chairman’s movement as they expressed dissatisfaction with his leadership of the electoral commission.

Reacting to the incident, Babalola argued that the demonstration should not be presented as the collective position of Nigerians in the United Kingdom.

According to him, nearly 200 Nigerian stakeholders and members of the diaspora attended the formal engagement inside Chatham House, making it misleading to portray the actions of a relatively small group outside the venue as representative of the wider Nigerian community.

The lawyer further alleged that the protesters were not necessarily acting out of genuine civic concerns but had allegedly been mobilised and paid to disrupt the event and attract public attention.

He also reportedly drew attention to political memorabilia worn by some of the demonstrators, suggesting that their appearance raised questions about possible political affiliations and the motivation behind the protest.

Babalola maintained that the formal engagement inside Chatham House and the demonstration outside the building were two separate events which should not be conflated.

He warned against using the actions of a handful of protesters to suggest that the wider Nigerian diaspora had collectively rejected the INEC chairman.

The allegations, however, have not been independently established, and the protesters’ account of the circumstances surrounding the demonstration remains important to a complete understanding of the incident.

The confrontation comes amid growing political disagreements over the preparedness of INEC for the 2027 general elections, particularly concerning the credibility of the voters’ register, electoral transparency, institutional independence and the security of the voting process.

Opposition figures and other critics have continued to scrutinise the commission’s activities, while INEC and its supporters have maintained that the electoral body should be allowed to carry out its constitutional responsibilities without undue political interference.

The London protest has consequently added another dimension to the debate over public confidence in Nigeria’s electoral institutions.

As of the time of filing this report, no independent evidence had been presented to establish Babalola’s allegation that the demonstrators were paid, while no formal response from the protest organisers addressing the claim was available.

The incident has also generated renewed discussions about the role of Nigerians in the diaspora in holding public institutions accountable and the need to distinguish genuine civic protests from demonstrations allegedly organised for political purposes.

Chatham House Protest: UK-Based Lawyer Alleges Anti-Amupitan Demonstrators Were Paid Actors

Loading

Continue Reading

Trending